Who Conducts an HOA Reserve Study?

Once your board agrees to commission a reserve study, the next question is obvious:

Who actually does this work, and how do we pick the right firm?

An HOA reserve study is not a simple spreadsheet exercise. It requires:

• Technical understanding of building systems and common elements
• Financial modeling skills to project long term cash flows
• Familiarity with industry standards and state requirements

In most communities, reserve studies are prepared by independent reserve study professionals or engineering firms who specialise in community associations. This article explains who they are, what credentials matter, and how to evaluate providers.

The Main Types of Reserve Study Providers

Associations typically work with one of three provider types.

1. Dedicated reserve study firms

These companies focus primarily on reserve studies for HOAs and condominiums. Their teams usually include people with backgrounds in construction, engineering or architecture and strong familiarity with community association finances.

Advantages:

• Deep experience with common components in HOAs and condos
• Processes built around CAI National Reserve Study Standards and similar frameworks
• Access to cost databases tailored to community association work

This is the most common option for typical associations.

2. Engineering and consulting firms

Civil or structural engineering firms and building envelope specialists sometimes provide reserve studies as part of a broader consulting practice. This can be particularly useful for:

• Complex buildings with structural or façade issues
• High rise condominiums
• Communities subject to enhanced safety or inspection rules

Here you are paying for additional technical depth, which can be worth it when risk is high.

3. Management companies and accountants

Some management companies and accounting firms offer simplified reserve analyses or partner with outside specialists. Whether this is appropriate depends on:

• Who is actually doing the physical and financial analysis
• Whether they follow recognised reserve study standards
• Whether they have the technical backing to support their conclusions

If a management company "includes" a reserve analysis, ask detailed questions about scope and credentials.

Key Qualifications To Look For

Not every jurisdiction requires specific licenses for reserve study work, but there are clear industry benchmarks.

National credentials

Two widely recognised designations are:

• Reserve Specialist (RS) from Community Associations Institute, which requires documented experience preparing reserve studies, references from clients, and adherence to CAI's professional standards.
• Professional Reserve Analyst (PRA) from the Association of Professional Reserve Analysts, which requires experience, peer review and compliance with APRA's Standards of Practice.

Boards do not have to insist on these letters, but they are strong signals that:

• The provider understands recognised standards
• The firm has meaningful experience with reserve planning for associations

Experience with communities like yours

Look for:

• A track record with properties similar in size and building type
• References from other HOAs or condos in your region
• Sample reports that clearly explain assumptions in plain language

High rise waterfront condos and small townhome communities have very different risk profiles. You want someone who has seen your type of building before.

Alignment with CAI and APRA standards

Ask directly:

• Whether the provider follows CAI's National Reserve Study Standards in their work.
• Whether their methodology is consistent with APRA's Standards of Practice for reserve studies.

That alignment matters when you discuss funding objectives, Fully Funded Balance, Percent Funded and types of reserve studies. 

What About State Law Requirements?

Some states do more than encourage reserve planning; they specify who may prepare a study or how independent the provider must be.

Examples include:

• Requirements that the study be performed by a person with particular professional credentials
• Independence rules, where the preparer cannot be an officer or director of the association
• Minimum standards for the scope of inspection and financial analysis

Your state's statutes and case law will shape how narrow or broad your choices are. Use a dedicated resource such as Reserve Study Requirements by State and, where appropriate, confirm details with association counsel.

How To Evaluate Reserve Study Proposals

Once you have a shortlist of providers, focus on more than just price.

Scope and level of service

Make sure each proposal spells out:

• Whether it is a full baseline study, an update with site visit or an update without site visit
• The length of the projection period, typically 20 to 30 years
• How many funding scenarios will be modeled
• Whether board or owner presentations are included

If you are not sure which level of study you need, review The 3 Types of Reserve Studies (Levels I to III) first.

If cost is a major concern for your board, see our guide on How Much Does an HOA Reserve Study Cost to understand typical pricing ranges.

Methodology and assumptions

Ask each provider:

• How they estimate remaining useful life
• How they build replacement cost estimates
• How they treat inflation, interest and contingencies

Communication and report quality

A technically excellent study is only useful if your board can understand it.

Ask for:

• Recent sample reports
• Confirmation that the final report will include an executive summary and clear charts
• Willingness to attend at least one board meeting to walk through findings

To get the most value out of that report once it arrives, see How To Read and Use Your Reserve Study.

Should Board Members Ever Do This Themselves?

Occasionally, boards consider writing their own "reserve study" or asking a handy volunteer to prepare one.

That approach is risky:

• Volunteers rarely have the combination of construction, engineering and financial expertise needed for accurate long term planning.
• Self prepared analyses are unlikely to carry much weight with lenders, buyers or courts.
• In states that require independent studies, a board generated document will not meet the legal test.

Boards can and should participate actively in the process by supplying data, reviewing assumptions and aligning funding decisions with community priorities. The actual technical work is best left to professionals.

For a preparation checklist covering what boards and managers should gather before the site visit, use Reserve Study Preparation Checklist for Boards and Managers.

Bringing It Back To The Big Picture

The question "Who conducts a reserve study?" is really about trust. You are asking an outside expert to:

• Translate your physical assets into numbers
• Project decades of spending
• Recommend funding paths that owners will have to live with

The safest route is to:

• Choose a firm that works with CAI and APRA standards
• Prioritise experience with communities like yours
• Treat the relationship as an ongoing partnership rather than a one off transaction

If your board wants help finding providers, platforms like PropFusion can connect you with reserve study companies in your state and make it easier to request multiple proposals with the right study type specified.